.png)
Florida Felony Scoresheets
Every felony sentence in Florida starts with arithmetic. Before any judge weighs who you are or what happened, the Criminal Punishment Code (§§ 921.002–921.0024, Florida Statutes) reduces the case to a scoresheet: points for the charge, points for injuries, points for your past, points for enhancements — run through a formula that produces the lowest permissible sentence the judge may impose. Most defendants see this document for the first time at sentencing, filled out by the State, with their future already added up.
That's backwards. The scoresheet should be the defense's document first — audited, challenged, and argued — because both of its pressure points are movable: the points themselves, and the legal grounds to go below the number they produce. Call or text 407-846-8008 and we'll score your case before the State does.
(The official Criminal Punishment Code scoresheet — Form 3.992(a) — is published by the Florida courts; we walk clients through every line of it.)
How the Math Works
• Primary offense points are set by your charge's offense severity level (1 through 10).
• Added to those: additional offense points for every other count, victim injury points (which climb steeply for penetration and severe injury), prior record points for your history, legal status points (on probation, pretrial release, or escape when the offense occurred), violation points, and enhancement multipliers for things like trafficking and gang findings.
• If total points are 44 or less, the lowest permissible sentence is a non-state-prison sanction — probation, county jail, community control — though the judge retains discretion up to the statutory maximum. For third-degree felonies scoring 22 points or fewer, the law goes further and requires a non-state-prison sentence — so long as the charge isn't a forcible felony or a burglary/trespass offense under chapter 810 — absent written findings that you'd present a danger to the public (§ 775.082(10)).
• If total points exceed 44, the formula is: (total points − 28) × 0.75 = the minimum prison months the judge must impose — unless a lawful basis exists to depart.
Two lessons hide in that formula. First, every point matters: at the margin, a few victim-injury points or a misclassified prior changes months into years. We verify every entry — priors that don't qualify, out-of-state convictions scored too high, injury points unsupported by the evidence — because State scoresheets do contain errors. Second, charge negotiation is sentence negotiation: dropping one additional count or reducing a severity level rewrites the bottom line before the judge ever rules.
Downward Departures: The Legal Exits Below the Minimum
A judge may sentence below the scoresheet minimum only with a valid legal ground under § 921.0026 — and it's the defense's job to build and prove one. The statute's list is expressly non-exhaustive (“include, but are not limited to”), and it includes:
• A legitimate, uncoerced plea bargain;
• The defendant was a minor participant / accomplice;
• Substantially impaired capacity to appreciate the conduct's criminal nature;
• The defendant requires specialized treatment for a mental disorder (unrelated to substance abuse) or physical disability, and is amenable to it;
• The need for restitution outweighs the need for prison;
• The victim initiated, provoked, or willingly participated in the incident;
• The defendant acted under extreme duress or another's domination;
• The victim was substantially compensated before the defendant was identified;
• Cooperation with the State;
• The offense was unsophisticated, isolated, and the defendant has shown remorse — the workhorse ground for first-time offenders;
• Youth and inability to appreciate consequences, or sentencing as a youthful offender;
• Amenability to drug court for qualifying nonviolent felonies scoring 60 points or fewer;
• A good-faith effort to get medical help during an overdose.
Two critical limits: substance abuse or intoxication is not, by itself, a lawful departure ground — the drug-court and treatment paths above are the lawful ways to bring addiction into sentencing. And a departure moves the scoresheet floor, not a separate statutory mandatory minimum: firearm (10-20-Life), drug-trafficking, and similar minimums are their own floors, which generally only the State can waive — one more reason the charging negotiation matters as much as the sentencing hearing. Departures must be supported by evidence (evaluations, records, witnesses) and found by the judge; an unpreserved or unsupported departure can be reversed on appeal. This is precisely the work a sentencing-focused defense lawyer does in the weeks before the hearing — not the morning of.
Frequently Asked Questions
The prosecutor says my scoresheet “requires prison.” Is that final?
It's the starting point, not the verdict. Point challenges, charge negotiation, and statutory departure grounds all exist to move it — and judges can use them when the groundwork is laid.
Can the judge go above the scoresheet?
Yes — up to the statutory maximum of each charge. The scoresheet sets the floor, not the ceiling. (In high-point cases the floor can even exceed the ordinary statutory maximum — when it does, the law requires the scoresheet number, § 921.0024(2).) Sentencing advocacy matters on both ends.
My prior convictions are decades old. Do they still score?
Prior record generally scores regardless of age, but what qualifies and how it's classified can be wrong on the State's draft. We pull certified records and re-score.
What is a “mitigation package”?
The evidence a departure stands on: treatment evaluations, work history, restitution proof, letters, expert reports — assembled and filed so the judge has lawful findings to make. It is the difference between asking for mercy and giving the court a legal path.
Score It Before They Do
Chad Seibel is a former prosecutor who has drafted hundreds of scoresheets from the State's side — and knows where they bend. Call or text 407-846-8008 for a free consultation. Office visits are by appointment only.