Child Abuse & Neglect Defense

No accusation turns a parent's life inside out faster. A bruise noticed at school, an ER doctor's hunch, a spanking reported by an angry ex, a toddler's wandering adventure — and suddenly there are two cases: a criminal prosecution and a DCF dependency case that can remove your children while the first one is pending. Both must be fought, in coordination, from day one — and one of the worst moves is the detailed “I can explain” interview parents give before calling anyone.

If DCF or a detective has contacted you about your child, call or text 407-846-8008 before the interview, not after.

​

The Charges Under § 827.03

• Child abuse — third-degree felony (up to 5 years): intentionally inflicting physical or mental injury on a child, committing an intentional act reasonably expected to cause such injury, or encouraging another to do so.

• Aggravated child abuse — first-degree felony (up to 30 years): aggravated battery on a child; willful torture or malicious punishment; or knowing abuse causing great bodily harm, permanent disability, or disfigurement.

• Neglect of a child: a caregiver's willful or culpably negligent failure to provide necessary care or supervision, or to protect the child from another's abuse. A third-degree felony — or a second-degree felony (up to 15 years) when the neglect causes great bodily harm.

“Mental injury” must be a substantial, discernible impairment proven by expert testimony — not hurt feelings — and “maliciously” means wrongfully and without legal justification, not strictly or imperfectly.

​

Discipline, Accidents, and the Lines the Law Actually Draws

• Reasonable corporal discipline is not a crime. Florida law has long recognized a parent's privilege to impose reasonable, non-injurious discipline. The line between a lawful spanking and “malicious punishment” is exactly what these prosecutions fight about — and the State carries the burden.

• Free-range parenting is protected — explicitly, since 2025. Florida law now states that letting a child engage in reasonable independent activities — walking or biking to school, playing outside, staying home for a reasonable time — is not neglect unless it's willful or wanton conduct that endangers the child. Charges built on “the kid was alone” run straight into this provision.

• Accidents are not abuse. Kids fall, burn themselves, break bones — constantly. The medical question (is this injury pattern truly diagnostic of abuse?) is contested science, and defense medical experts can often answer the State's with accidental mechanisms the detectives never considered.

• Poverty alone is not criminal neglect. The State must prove a willful or culpably negligent failure — not merely imperfect circumstances. Missed appointments, imperfect housing, and supervision gaps born of two jobs and no childcare call for support, not prosecution, and courts recognize the difference when it's actually argued.

​

The Two-Front War: Criminal Court and DCF

The dependency case moves faster than the criminal one, with lower standards and demands for statements, evaluations, and case-plan admissions — all discoverable by prosecutors. Coordinating both matters enormously: what reunifies your family in dependency court must not convict you in criminal court. The criminal defense has to be built with the dependency case in view — coordinated with dependency counsel — so both tracks follow one strategy.

​

Frequently Asked Questions

DCF wants to interview me and “it's voluntary.” Should I go?

Not alone, and not unprepared. Cooperation can be right — structured, with counsel, after we know the allegation. Unstructured candor is how parents prosecute themselves.

My ex reported me during our custody case.

The family-court origin is evidence — of motive and timing — and it's one of the most common fact patterns in false-allegation prosecutions. Preserve every message.

The doctor says the injury “is consistent with abuse.”

“Consistent with” is not “caused by.” Pediatric injury interpretation has a contested scientific history, and a defense medical expert is often essential in these cases.

Will my kids be taken while this is pending?

Removal is DCF's decision subject to court review, and it's fought at a shelter hearing within days. Call immediately — that hearing is hard to win from behind.

​

Your Family Is the Case — Defend It Like One

Chad Seibel is a former prosecutor who has handled child-victim cases from both sides and knows how they're built — and how they're taken apart. Call or text 407-846-8008 for a free, confidential consultation. Office visits are by appointment only.